Friday, 23 January 2015

Persolaise Review: La Religieuse from Serge Lutens (Christopher Sheldrake; 2015)

Waiting for the next Lutens release has almost become like anticipating the next movie from Terrence Malick. Granted, Uncle Serge doesn't exercise our patience quite as much as Malick does, but the narrative cohesiveness of his recent perfumes has been so pronounced that the arrival of a new one sparks exactly the sorts of questions that could be asked of a creation from a cinema auteur: how will it pick up from where the previous one concluded? what will it have to say about x, y and z? in which direction will it push the body of work as a whole? It's not surprising, then, that it was with considerable excitement that I wore Lutens' latest olfactory tale, La Religieuse, put together by his regular perfumer, Christopher Sheldrake.

When I first learned what this new scent's name was going to be - Diderot reference notwithstanding - I quipped that it would probably smell like Maria Von Trapp lying on a bed of choux pastry and chocolate ganache. But even as I cracked the lame joke, I guessed the nun reference was an indicator that the perfume would pull us back into the territory through which Lutens has wandered for the last 3 or 4 years. I wasn't wrong. In 2011/12, his Jeux De Peau and Santal Majuscule were like an explosion of reminiscence, using gourmand notes to make insistent statements about childhood. Then the mood began to darken. In 2013, La Fille De Berlin emphasised the pain of looking back, using its sub-zero rose to evoke the anguish of nostalgia. And last year, with L'Orpheline, the tone became even more introspective, balancing heartache with tenderness. La Religieuse feels very much like the next instalment in this increasingly absorbing story; after all, its name alludes to yet another female figure.

On an objective level, the scent is a soapy floral. The pre-release material has suggested that its main note is jasmine - and white petals are definitely present - but it's years away from the grandiloquent voice of A La Nuit and Sarrasins. In fact, the animalic aspect of the jasmine seems to have been eradicated completely, to be replaced by much more quietly-spoken blooms, namely honeysuckle, narcissus and mimosa. The wispy bouquet is tied with a translucent ribbon of grass and wrapped in a familiar-smelling embrace of velvety musks. It doesn't sound hard-hitting and indeed, it isn't. Think of Jean-Claude Ellena's La Haie Fleuri (L'Artisan Parfumeur) and you'll get a sense of its breath-on-the-wind elusiveness.

However, it becomes more interesting when placed within the narrative context described above. L'Orpheline was frightened, uncertain, full of trepidation, but La Religieuse begins to venture into the world with a tiny bit more confidence. It's still hesitant, likely to curl its petals into a ball at the first sign of danger, but it also allows itself to succumb to the enticements of optimism: somewhere, at the edge of its virtuous garden lies an open meadow, filled with the sins and purities of a world beyond a picket fence.

That said, for all its verdant innocence, the perfume isn't always easy to read. Its minimalist aesthetic brings with it a reluctance to reveal all its secrets. Yes, the floral line running through its centre is lucid, but it's punctuated by several perplexing, decidedly synthetic accents. These range from almost-unnoticeable incense notes, to a barely-there ghost of blackcurrants, and even, brace yourselves, an intimation of Johnson's baby shampoo, circa 1985. The latter may well be nothing more than a sly wisecrack on Sheldrake's part - was there a French equivalent of the stuff and, if so, could Lutens have been aware of it? - but nonetheless, it's intriguing. With its evocation of childhood bath rituals and steamy rooms filled with soap suds, it ties in with the fragrance's 'juvenile' plot, but it also appears to make a wider comment about mainstream perfumery's current obsession with fruity shampoo accords. If Lutens' Eaux series is an attempt to find new ways of saying 'clean' in perfume-speak, then perhaps La Religieuse tries to suggest that not all 'bath product scents' have to be mindless clones of each other, although it's probably too demure to cause mainstream perfume styles to change in any meaningful way.

It may be less comforting and emotive than L'Orpheline, but its circumspect gracefulness makes La Religieuse an endearing addition to the Lutens collection. It's quiet, but there's definitely a heart beating at its core, a heart hoping to find the courage to leave childhood behind... which leads me to ask the inevitable question: how long do we have to wait for the chapter in which our little heroine grows up?

[Review based on a sample of eau de parfum provided by Serge Lutens in 2015.]



  1. Reading your reviews, I find myself wanting to try some fragrances that I'm not even actually interested in just because your descriptions are so fluid and poetic! That being said, I'd have gone for this Lutens anyday, anyway - it's right up my street. Thanks for the gorgeous (as usual) review!

    1. Jenn, thanks very much indeed. If/when you try La Religieuse, I'd love to know what you make of it.

  2. Can't wait to try this one! To be honest, it doesn' really sound like my cup of tea, but I can't leave a new Lutens release alone...thanks for giving us an idea of what to expect!

    1. Ruth, thanks for stopping by. I agree that a new Lutens is always worth trying :-)

  3. Looking forward to trying this one, thanks for the early review.

    I can't say "soapy" is up my alley, and if the incense isn't a strong presence, it probably won't be something for me. I was HORRIFIED by Vierge de Fer and it's disgusting shampoo-notes....hoping that isn't going to become a trend.

    1. Anon, thanks for bringing up Vierge De Fer. La Religieuse is much quieter and more subtle, but the two scents do occupy a similar 'soapy floral' territory, I'm afraid. Still, a new Lutens is always worth checking out, right?


Thanks very much for reading my site and taking the time to leave a comment.

Please note that whilst the full range of views is welcome on, comments containing expletives and/or abusive language may not be published.

If you're using Safari on an Apple device, you may experience some difficulties with submitting comments. Please consider using Google's Chrome browser on your Apple device; this may make it easier to leave your comment.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...