Friday, 14 September 2012

Persolaise Review: Coco Noir from Chanel and Grand Bal from Christian Dior (2012)

Whilst watching Joe Wright's over-egged version of Anna Karenina, I wondered if the impeccably groomed counts and countesses waltzing across the screen could possibly have worn François Demachy's new Grand Bal (the latest addition to Dior's Collection Privée). In the end, I decided that the answer was No, but I hasten to point out that this is by no means a criticism.

Granted, Demachy took his inspiration from lavish soirees held in France in the 40s - a setting rather different from Tolstoy's Russia - but even so, it's difficult to see the connection between ball gowns and the accord that lies at the heart of this perfume: a gorgeous, heady, translucent jasmine. Never mind. This is an occasion where an apparent misalignment of smell and name doesn't matter one bit. Dashing as far away as it possibly can from stately interiors, Demachy's scent takes us into lush tropical landscapes, where white flowers (the aforementioned jasmine, together with ylang ylang and orange blossom) are lifted by the faintest hints of fruity notes, diffused by sunlight reflecting off fresh green facets and grounded by subtle musks.

If all this sounds familiar, that's because most of it is: Grand Bal doesn't break new ground in any way whatsoever. But I suspect Demachy wasn't trying to be innovative here. Instead, he's shown that sometimes the best recipes are the old ones, as long as they're put together using high-quality materials and given a few modern embellishments. With elegant sensuality, Grand Bal takes its place next to À La Nuit, Beyond Paradise and Dior's own J'Adore L'Absolu as one of the most instantly charming modern jasmines on the market. If someone had sent Anna a bottle of this stuff, perhaps things between her and Karenin might have worked out differently...

In brief... Christopher Sheldrake and Jacque Polge's Coco Noir for Chanel doesn't re-invent the wheel either, but I'm afraid I can't award it quite the same praise as Demachy's effort. Contrary to its publicity material, it isn't byzantine, it isn't baroque and it isn't even especially noir. Indeed, housed inside its portentously opaque bottle is that most ubiquitous of current olfactory creations: a fruity, musky patchouli oriental. It cannot be denied that it is an extremely pleasant fruity, musky patchouli oriental - with occasional flashes of the original Coco's spices and Coco Mademoiselle's sweet tooth - but surely, for a high-profile follow-up to one of their most beloved scents, Chanel could have gone for any genre other than the one which causes critics to despair about the future of mainstream perfumery. Ah, but of course they're not making perfumes for critics. They're making them for the bottom line. And I suspect they'll have a hit on their hands by the time Christmas shopping reaches its peak. I won't complain too much, though. At least the scent isn't downright offensive, like Bleu. And its vanillic drydown is rather lovely. But Coco Noir sees Chanel locked in a holding pattern. If their next release doesn't move things along, I might not be quite so forgiving.

[Review of Grand Bal based on a sample of eau de parfum provided by Christian Dior in 2012; review of Coco Noir based on a sample of eau de parfum provided by Chanel in 2012.]



  1. The Scentimentalist15 September 2012 at 11:29

    Thank you. I enjoyed this. I couldn't hate on Coco Noir owing to its allusions to the wondrous Coco -- but, please. Naked disappointment.

    1. Scentimentalist, thanks very much. At least Coco Noir isn't as disappointing as Bleu, eh?

  2. So I wait to be able to buy a Coco Noir mini! bottle online :-) Thank you for the always good advice!!

    1. Linda, if you get hold of some, let me know what you think of it.

  3. Hello. As a perfume newbie, I'm really enjoying learning more through your blog.

    I loved the name and the bottle, but the perfume gave me flashback memories to cherries in syrup that we used to have as a dessert in the 70s...

    1. Annie, thanks very much indeed. I hope you continue to enjoy reading my work.

      Cherries in syrup, eh? I can see why you might have got that image.

  4. Thank you very much for your awesome review! I am very new in the wonderful world of scents and emotional attachment associated with olfactory experiences. But I do try to put my nose in as many perfumes as possible. I adore A la nuit but often it turns out to be too much of good a thing. Alas J'adore does not sit well on my skin and jasmine that is supposed to be airy and full of light never makes an appearance! Oh well I blame it on reformulation then!
    Grand Bal is respite in many ways. I did not really expected anything and was smitten instantly. Its like looking at a grand "Mogra" with a background of diffused light passing through a crystal. <3

    1. Rubberneck, thanks for stopping by. I know what you mean about A La Nuit being too much of a good think, but I love it :-)

      I'm glad you enjoyed Grand Bal.


Thanks very much for reading my site and taking the time to leave a comment.

Please note that whilst the full range of views is welcome on, comments containing expletives and/or abusive language may not be published.

If you're using Safari on an Apple device, you may experience some difficulties with submitting comments. Please consider using Google's Chrome browser on your Apple device; this may make it easier to leave your comment.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...